15% off membership for Easter! Learn more. Close

Design a door for the visually impaired.

Asked at Microsoft
2.7k views
Answers (2)
To answer this question, Log in.
crownAccess expert answers by becoming a member

You'll get access to over 3,000 product manager interview questions and answers

badge Platinum PM

Understanding

Before we dive into this problem, let's make sure we understand it correctly. What is our rationale for taking on this project, what does our company do, is there a larger strategic imperative we should align ourselves with or can we just focus solely on providing a really good experience to our users? Let's just focus on providing a good user experience.

There are all kinds of doors in all kinds of different places. This could be a door in a public space like a restaurant or store, a car door, a door into a house, or even a door inside of a house or building like a bathroom door. For the sake of this question, let's assume it is a front door for a house.

User Segments

Now that we have a better understanding of the question, let's break down our users into different segments and pick one to focus on. Right away the first thing that comes to mind is to segment these users based upon their level of visual impairment because that will dictates their needs are:

  1. Fully Blind - Cannot see anything, pitch black darkness
  2. Significantly visually impaired - Still legally blind, but can make out shapes and colors
  3. Can't see without glasses - Definitely still visually impaired, but can get by okay so long as they have their glasses on

Out of the above user segments, I'm going to suggest we focus on the fully blind user segment. This is the user segment that deviates the most from the norm so there is really more of an opportunity here to provide a great user experience as they have more of a need. Furthermore, a solution that helps someone who is fully blind will also help someone who is partially blind as well.

Needs / Pain Points

  1. Need to know if the door is open or closed
  2. Need to know if there is anything blocking the door way
  3. Need to be able to find the handle to open the door easily
  4. Need to be able to know who has rung the doorbell without opening it
  5. Need to know if the door is locked or not

Solutions

Now that we have a better understanding of the user's needs and pain points let's go ahead and brainstorm some solutions:

  1. Voice Activated Door - We could wire the door to respond to voice commands, such as open, close, lock. The door could respond back with a pleasant tone when done with the request. This could use voice recognition to recognize a list of users who are allowed to give it voice commands, or voice commands could only work if a fob is within x distance.
  2. Voice Panel: Very similar to how there is an peephole for the non-visually impaired to see who is on the other side, we could make a small section of the door, around mouth level, be made of a different material that would let sound pass through it more effectively. This way the visually impaired user could vocally inquire as to who is on the other side of the door before opening it to a robber or even worse, a jehova's witness.
  3. Textured Gradient: We could put a textured gradient on the door near the handle so that the texture is rougher closer to where the door knob is. This would better help users find where the handle is, think about trying to find a light switch in the dark.
  4. Magnetic key and lock: I am not visually impaired but still struggle with getting the key into the lock. Could we magnetize the key and lock such that they attract each other when nearby and perhaps change the shape of the key so it is easier to fit in the lock, maybe even switch to a tap based key card reader.
Prioritization
Assuming we don't have all of the resources available to build all of these solutions in parallel, let's pick one to prioritize. To help us do this, I'll use the following matrix:
 
User Satisfaction, Ease of Implementation, Monetizability
1. A+, C-, A-
2. B, B+, B
3. B+, A, B-
4. B+, B+, B
 
Based off of the above prioritization matrix, I'm to suggest we focus on building out solution #1 which is the Voice Activated Door. I think by far this is going to be the most resource intensive solution to build out, but the balance to that is that it will have the biggest impact on our ability to give a really great experience to our users which is our goal. 
 
Furthermore and thinking down the road here, I think this feature could really be our foot in the door to building out a more fully integrated accessibility IOT app. For users to use our door and ensure strangers can't unlock it with their own voice, they would need to register their smart phone through our app. We could then use our app as a platform for their other accessibility based smart devices. For example, they could register their thermostat and have our app read out the settings and take voice commands to increase or decrease the temperature. This would give us the ability to evolve from a single product into a platform thus increasing our opportunity to both help our users and monetize our offering.
 
 
 
 
Access expert answers by becoming a member
0 likes   |  
1 Feedback
badge Platinum PM

 

Summary

You did a great job.  Please take all feedback as suggestions and mild tweaks.

Things you did well

1.        Clarifying questions – you asked two really important questions

a.        why are we doing this?  I see so many folks not ask that important question. 

b.       Clarified what type of door the interviewer was talking about. 

2.       Persona and User segments – again great job.  You could throw in non-visually impaired users as well and comment that they are in there as a check – any solution should not reduce the doors utility for the non-visually impaired.

3.       Pick a user persona to focus on using criteria – check

4.       Pain points – check

5.       Solutions – 3-4 solutions including a moon shot – Not sure your voice activated door counts as a moon shot – but great job. 

6.       Pick a solution using criteria – check.  As a note I use Reach, Impact, Effort – RICE without the confidence coefficient.  Tell them you are using a simplified RICE – show them you know this method. 

Things you could improve

1.        Pick a pain point to focus on using some criteria – like you did with persona

2.       Solutions if you pick a pain point then all your solutions can solve that pain point – as an FYI your solution of a voice activated door that opens, closes and locks does not technically match your pain points – I can infer that it solves knowing if the door is open or closed, I can infer that I don’t need to find the handle because the door opens, I can infer that the I know if the door is locked or not.  I am being really picayune – your answer was great – so just take this as very technical feedback. 

3.       Watch your jokes – I love to show off my sense of humor I routinely take cracks at my kids - read my answer on Design a bookshelf for kids - but your joke “or even worse, a jehova's witness” could get you dinged for social, cultural and religious insensitivity. 

4.       Always a bonus to identify the metrics of success and limitations (swing back to non-visually impaired persona – does this cause them any issues)

Again a solid answer. 

 

0
Get unlimited access for $12/month
Get access to 2,346 pm interview questions and answers to give yourself a strong edge against other candidates that are interviewing for the same position
Get access to over 238 hours of video material containing an interview prep course, recorded mock interviews by expert PMs, group practice sessions, and QAs with expert PMs
Boost your confidence in PM interviews by attending peer to peer mock interview practices, group practices, and QA sessions with expert PMs
badge Platinum PM
This is quite an interesting and challenging problem I would say because door is such a simple product + I think one of the main issues is that I have fortunately never lived a life of a visually impaired person. But let me ask you few questions so I can make sure I am solving for the correct thing.

I assume that by door we mean any door in the house. Or do we also mean doors at restaurants and such? (upto you).

Ok, I will choose doors in teh house for now just because I think that's under the control of a person who might buy my product (be it a door or any other tech) and the consumer is the buyer so I think it be easier to enter the market that way first. However, maybe depending on solution I design, it may be applicable to other markets as well. (Interviewer: ok)

For me, can we focus on US? I think this matter because in countries like India, doors have olden style latch so product design would be unique.

Interviewer: ok.

Also, it could be tech hardware product or software or even a non-tech product? What's your choice? (Interviewre: upto you).

Ok I think I am likely to make a tech product. And is there a certain type of visually imparied we are thinking of? (No; upto you again).

And also is there a reason we are doing this? I mean, do we have certain data whereby current customers are requesting to help them due to visually impaired family members? Is it ton of data points? Or is it leadership mandate? Is there a reason leadership has asked us to do this? (interviwer: leadership mandate. We don't know why).

Do we already do business selling doors or just windows or other home improvement hardware or is this a new business? (Interviewer: new business).

Ok, so then I take it that we want to be disruptive. And I take it this would be our first product. If you are ok with those assumptions, then I would want to focus on designing a product that can attract customers since I think as a new biz to survive i will need to focus on acquisition.

Interviewer: Sounds great!

Me: As a Lead PM I typicalyl think of who my user is since that helps me think of what might help that user and then I design a solution. I then am faced with trade-offs and challenges and constraints and based on all that I end up prioritizing features on roadmap. I think a similar approach might work well. What do you think?

Interviewer: sure.

Me; When I  think of visually imparied i think the product should address just anyone who is visually impaired but then we also have different age groups. I think kids have a unique requirement but after a certain age no matter how old your requirements are prob the same. Except, I think older people may have some unique needs as well (like you have to consider their deteriorating health, phyiscal weaknes, etc.). I think I would focus on elderly here because everyone other than kids and elderly are generally active and have learnt the doors and such in teh house well and can remember it. They also are accustomed to the challenge and using the doors fine. But elderly have memory issues and physical strength that's reudcing so that might posee more challenges for them. Kids on the other hand, have no patience and are always in a rush and also can't reach handle of the door sometimes to be able to open it. Biut I think focusing on elderly will likely address kids as well + kids learn to be fearful due to disability quite fast and parents of these kids usually have a strong watch on them so I think elderly is the odd man out. Addressing for them wil address for everyone.

Interviewer: ok.

Me: As a visually impaired, do we mean 100% blind? Mostly yes. ok let's go with yes since even if not 100%, assuming 100% will solve for most cases. I tink they encounter troubles such as 1) identifying where handle is 2)not enough strength to turn the handle 3) loss of balance so fear of falling and high risk of falling.

I think all of these are important so I would like to design for all of these to make it a attractive enough product to acquire customers. But after solutioning, I will wnat to re-evaluate if we shoul ship all features. However, in the meantime I would lke to also think how I will know the success of my product. I think it's important to think of that now since if we knnow what to focus on that might help think of prioritizing my solution and maybe even designing the product.

Success measures: 1)# of net new customers 2)increase in QTY ordered 3) # of replacements ordered / customer. For this #3 I would want to see number go down since higher number here tells me product quality is poor which will impact future biz. I am not thinking of $ since our goal is not revenue but getting product to the masses. Now that we know our focus, let's think of waht features can help us possibly attain our goal.

Solutions:

1) Wrist band that vibrates as you approach the door. The closer to the door the stronger the vibration. Maybe I think wrist band would be wide enough that we can have vibration in middle, left, and right side. This is because if the door is on right of you vibrates on right, in front of you vibrates in middle, etc. In fact, we could even consider distance. So maybe 1 cm in front or vibrating 2 cm in front. that be the max prob or may 3 cm in front since wrist is likely not gonna be broader than that.

2) You can likely just push button to open the door but since elderly have reducing stregth this should be tough sensitive. Infact, with wrist band on you prob don't even need to touch. It just opens. But I thik there is risk to this since you may not want tthe door to just open by proximity (what if this is a basement door?). So maybe a setting where by you control these yes automated door open vs. not. auto open might be imp when my elderly customer is sick and wants to immediately go to bathroom.

3) I think we should also have it voice controlled. This will require NLP and it may need some training. There is a risk since no matter the training some accents are hard. Maybe we can support multi language capability here but I think this might be an enhancement.

4) I think a long far stretched think might be that we and design a tech product whereby a wire or something is installed with your brain (electro magnetic current) and a hanging fashionable neckless (could be sold in diff colors) could see the door in front, translates the signals to your brain and allows you to haev a vision through an AR/VR glass. I honestly don't evne know if this is possible and seems like something out of sci-fi. Compelxity is super high on this prob and will require miuch research. I doubt this is something we should consider for 1st release / launch. We can continue RD on this though.

For now I think these are good amount of solutions. I think complexity of implementation for #2 is 2 (on scale of 1 to 5, 5 being the highest) and Value to customer is 5. I would do this. #1 I think has C=3, V=5 (it gives signals to customer on where the door is so I think customer would appreciate it). I would do this as well. And #1 and #2 can equally be done together for 1st release. #3 I thikn has higher C =4 and V=5. #4 C=5, V=3. Value is lower on this because this will mean my customer will have to have something hooked to their body and no one likes that. Especially, this is going to make my customer feel inferior and odd man out in public. No one likes that! It's like drawing attention to your disability. I think I would want to conduct some research to indicate how my customers would feel psychologically about this.

I would go with release #1 and #2 as 1st release and post that start developing #3 and #4 will likely be in research phase.

All in all, desiging a door for visually blind I think is more important for an elderly. The solutions we prioritized I think are cool enough that even a non-visually impaired would be attracted to so I think we could pssibly gain more customers than expected.
Access expert answers by becoming a member
0 likes   |  
Get unlimited access for $12/month
Get access to 2,346 pm interview questions and answers to give yourself a strong edge against other candidates that are interviewing for the same position
Get access to over 238 hours of video material containing an interview prep course, recorded mock interviews by expert PMs, group practice sessions, and QAs with expert PMs
Boost your confidence in PM interviews by attending peer to peer mock interview practices, group practices, and QA sessions with expert PMs
Get unlimited access for $12/month
Get access to 2,346 pm interview questions and answers to give yourself a strong edge against other candidates that are interviewing for the same position
Get access to over 238 hours of video material containing an interview prep course, recorded mock interviews by expert PMs, group practice sessions, and QAs with expert PMs
Boost your confidence in PM interviews by attending peer to peer mock interview practices, group practices, and QA sessions with expert PMs