Estimate the number of actual COVID-19 positive people in India as of today.
You'll get access to over 3,000 product manager interview questions and answers
Recommended by over 100k members
Approach:
1. Identify the no. of international travellers entering India every day
2. Identify the total no. of infected people out of this population
3. Identify the average contacts made by an infected person in a day and newly infected people because of this person
4. Identify the total infected people because of the new arrivals, new contacts made and disease tranmission rate before lockdown and social distancing happened
5. Identify the total infected people by April 27th (after social distancing)
6. Identify the total no. of positive cases by April 27th (Would be lesser since symtoms start appearing after 14 days)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Identify the no. of international travellers entering India every day
There are 30 international airports in India with 7 major ones including Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai, Kochi, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Kolkata.
Delhi Airport receives around 800-2200 international passengers during lean and peak hours every day which makes amounts to a total of 30000 (~1200*24 hours) international passengers everyday.
So, total no. of international passengers entering India everyday could be estimated at 1 lakh per day.
(Delhi - 30K, Mumbai - 20K, Chennai - 15K, Kochi - 10K, Bangalore - 8 K, Hyderabad - 6 K, Kolkata - 5 K and so on..)
2. Identify the total no. of infected people out of this population
Assuming the infected ratio to be 1% (taking into consideration the worldwide disease spread % which is not very high), the total no. of positive cases on the first day = 1000 people
3. Identify the average contacts made by an infected person in a day and newly infected people because of this person
Depending on the lifestyle of the person, contacts made by a person can vary from 5 to 50 people on an average with median standing at 10 people.
Assuming the disease transmission rate to be 1% (As the no. of positive cases doubles every 10th day), new people getting infected by one infected person everyday would be .1 people on an average
4. Identify the total infected people because of the new arrivals, new contacts made and disease tranmission rate before lockdown and social distancing happened
Day 1 - C = 1000 positive cases - X1
Day 2 - X1 + X1*.1 + W2 = X1*1.1 + C = 1000*1.1 + 1000 = 2100 positive cases - X2
Day 3 - X2 + X2*.1 + W3 = X2*1.1 + C = 2100*1.1 + 1000 = 3310 positive cases - X3
and so on...
So total no. of infected people by March 20th (Before social distancing and lockdown happened) would be 1163909 ~ 11 Lakh infected people
5. Identify the total infected people by April 27th
Assuming that after the lockdown and social distancing the transmission rate reduced to .01% from .1% and since international travel was stopped, there were no new cases coming from international travel.
So, total no. of infected people by April 27th (37 days) would be 1522635 ~ 15 lakh infected people
6. Identify the total no. of positive cases by April 27th
Total no. of positive cases by April 27th would be the total no. of infected people by April 13th (since it takes 14 days before any symptoms appear)
so total no. of positive cases by April 27th would be 1324636 ~ 13 lakh positive cases
So, total no. of positive cases in India by April 27th would be 13 lakh.
Assumptions: There is no real way to find the actual initial no. of affected cases, as lots of cases may not be reported. Hence, I’m estimating on the basis of people probably affected then drilling down further to see the total estimated cases-
Equation: No. of people in India * contact rate * % of people contracting through contact.
Where,
- Contact rate = Avg no. of people who’d probably be affected through contact (% of people who’ll be in contact/ person)
- % of people contracting though contact= Not all people who are in contact with covid-19 positive will contract the disease, hence this metric measures the probability of actual disease contraction
Total population of India= 1.3B
Inorder to calculate contact rate, defining Population by where they live-
Without social distancing:
Population lives in | % of population | Population | Contact Rate | Disease Contraction rate | Infected population | Total affected population |
Highly populous cities | 10% | 130M | Very high (1 person infects 200 people) i.e: 650,000 infected people will infect 130M | 40% | =40%*650,000 = 260K infected | 260K + (infected potential affecting regular population =52M, who inturn have 40% contraction rate) i.e 21.49M |
Tier 2 cities | 20% | 260M | Very High (1 person infects 150 people) i.e 1.73M infected people will infect 260M) | 40% | =40% *1.73M= 692K infected | 692K + (infected potential affecting regular population =103M, who intur have 40% contract rate) i.e 41.89M |
Tier 3 cities | 30% | 390M | High (1 person infects 100 people) i.e: 3.9M infected people will infect 390M | 30% | =30%*3.9M = 1.17M | 1.17M + (infected potential affecting regular population= 117M, who in turn have 30% contract rate)= 36.27MM (1.17+35.1)
|
Villages | 40% | 420M | Medium ( 1 person infects 20 people) i.e: 21M infected people will affect 420M | 70% | =70%*21M= 14.7M | 294M (who in turn have 70% contract rate)+ 14.7M = 205.8+14.7= 220.5M |
Thus, total infected due to not following social distancing could be 320.15MM people.
However, due to rigorous social distancing measures taken by India, my assumption is that only 20 % of the actual population calculated may be affected= 0.2*320.15MM ~64MM people.
Assuming 3000 people have been affected till date, and a further assumption that only 50% people who have the disease have been tested so far, actual cases comes to 6000 then for calculating more potential cases
Hypothesis : No. of infected people in India * contact rate * % of people contracting through contact = Total potentially affected people
Segregating on the basis of population density :
Densely populated – 30% = 1800
Quarantined : 50% affects 4 person directly = 3600
Not Quarantined : 50% affects 15person directly = 11,500
Moderate populated : 45% = 2700
Quarantined : 50% affects 2 person directly = 2700
Not Quarantined : 50% affects 9 person directly = 1350x9 = 13500-1350 = 11,150
Less Populated: 25% = 1500
Quarantined : 50% affects 2 person directly = 1500
Not Quarantined : 50% affects 5 person directly = 3750
Final count = 6000 + 3750+11150+2700+11500+3600 = 38,700
Now this is assuming no community transmission. Once that is established and more tests are conducted that number maybe around 10%
Now splitting 1 billion Indians in North (30%), West (30%), South (25%) and East (15%).
Keeping in mind the population density and education levels, I am assuming the following percentages will be affected in the regions:
North 20%
West 20%
South 10%
East 10%
Thus total number of patients is 1B*(0.3*0.20 + 0.3*0.20 + 0.25*0.10 + 0.15*0.10) = 160 million
Top interview questions
- What is your favorite product? Why?89 answers | 263k views
- How would you design a bicycle renting app for tourists?62 answers | 82.5k views
- Build a product to buy and sell antiques.54 answers | 66.8k views
- See Google PM Interview Questions
Top Estimation interview questions
- Calculate the number of queries answered by Google per second.45 answers | 78.5k views
- How do you decide how many cash registers you need for a new Walmart store?33 answers | 39.4k views
- How many dentists are there in New York?33 answers | 36.7k views
- See Estimation PM Interview Questions
Top interview questions
- How would you improve Google Maps?53 answers | 228k views
- A metric for a video streaming service dropped by 80%. What do you do?50 answers | 135k views
- How would you design a web search engine for children below 14 years old?36 answers | 42.9k views
- See Google PM Interview Questions
Top Estimation interview questions
- Estimate the number of Uber rides.30 answers | 51.3k views
- Estimate the number of bicycles required to start a bike sharing operation in a big city.18 answers | 15.8k views
- Estimate the number of WhatsApp chats occuring in India.14 answers | 13.3k views
- See Estimation PM Interview Questions