One of the brands in the grocery category is not selling and has stocks left that are soon to expire. Specify all possible reasons for it and also suggest solutions for each of the reasons.
You'll get access to over 3,000 product manager interview questions and answers
Recommended by over 100k members
First I will ask clarifying questions to better understand the situation.
Then I will brainstorm possible reasons and suggest solutions for each reason.
Clarifying Qs
1. Which grocery category? Dairy, fruits/veggies, meat, canned goods, beverages, cereals, snacks (cookies & chips), breads, or anything I missed? Snacks
2. Which brand in that category? Oreos
3. Where is this grocery located? What country, state, city, neighborhood (urban, suburban)? Mom and pop grocery store in a suburban neighborhood
4. How long has the brand "not been selling?" Are other brands in this category or in other categories not selling that I should be aware of? Two months, no other brands are suffering
5. How soon will it expire? In a year, but it should have sold already. Packaged snacks have a lont shelf-life.
6. How much stock is left? Too much.
7. Any internal factors I should be aware of? Oreos are on a high/low/unaccessible shelf, price unusually high, other items in that category better featured or at better prices, new competitor for Oreos, new shop management? No
8. Any external factors I should be aware of? Crime in shop local, inclement weather conditions, new grocery shop opened nearby, change in consumer preferences? Yes, trend towards healthier foods
Brainstorm possible reasons and suggest solutions for each reason
Reason: Global trend towards healthier foods, people want to eat nutritious snacks and are consuming less junk food.
Solution: Follow the trend, do not fight it. Offer Oreos at a discount to get rid of them quickly before the expiration date or give them away for free.
Moving forward, work with distributers to stock more healthy snacks and less unhealthy snacks to meet consumer needs. To stay on top of trends in the future, poll consumers periodically and stay informed of current events by reading news, watching TV and observing.
Clarify
- Define " not selling" - was it selling before, now paused or never picked up?
- What was the reason behind the introduction of this brand?
- Define " soon" - how much time, how much qyt, how many days of stock basis current sell rate, how much we need to sell to avoid expiry
- About the category and brand
- What is the customer trigger to buy?
- What qty they buy and how frequently?
- Where do they buy from ?
- What factors decide where they buy from?
- Any external factors - regulatory, GT-MT dumping or competition liquidating their inventory at rock bottom prices?
- How is the overall category doing- is the brand an anamoly
- Awareness - how do these metric look compared to category and largest competitor
- Impressions Served
- CTRs
- Search rank trending
- Consideration
- Price & Offers
- Product Description
- Ratings- customer and seller
- Views given to brand and eventually bought by competitor : Co Browsing loss?
- Purchase
- Views
- GV to sales
- % Delivery quality issues/ Customer complaints
- % Abandoned Cart
- Time to deliver is worse off than promised
- Repeats %
Clarifying Questions:
1. Which grocery category? Snacks
2. Is it an online shop or mom and pop grocery? Online shop
3. How long has the brand "not been selling?" Are other brands in this category or in other categories not selling that I should be aware of? Two months, no other brands are suffering
4. How soon will it expire? In six month
5. How much stock is left? Too much.
We can interview some people who bought other brands to figure out the exact reasons, but generally my assumptions are:
1.this brand's products are not displayed because of tech problems
2. this brand's products are displayed in the last page of products and no one see them
3. Very bad comments have been written about it
4. It has a higher price than similar products
5. The purchase option for this brand has a bug
6. Users boycotted this brand for some reason
Solutions:
1.communicate with engineering team to solve the problem
2.communicate with engineering team to show this brand's products in the first pages
3.read those comments carefully and remove them if they are unreal
4.negotiate with the its company to offer some discounts
5.communicate with engineering team to solve the problem
6.ask the company for advertisement and rebranding and also offer discounts
Possible Reason | Solution |
Brand not well known, brand perception has gone down | Brand needs to improve/add content to promote its products as well as use advertising to promote its product. Provide suggestions to brand on how to improve its content based on similar listings (ex: keywords, images). |
Product category/categories too saturated | Increase promotion of products by suggesting discount/sales that the product can join or ads that the brand can use to boost sales |
New, emerging brands appeared that brand did not foresee so has extra stock | Help brand position itself against competitors through new content suggestions |
External factors (ex: COVID-19 where products without certain attributes didn't sell as well) | Offer brand to provide free add-ons to existing orders to help complete stock and promote product usage |
Top Amazon interview questions
- A metric for a video streaming service dropped by 80%. What do you do?50 answers | 135k views
- Design a library for the future.25 answers | 23.5k views
- Your new feature boosts Amazon Search by 10%, adds 2s to load time. What do you do?19 answers | 36k views
- See Amazon PM Interview Questions
Top Problem Solving interview questions
- Drivers are dropping out of a city on Lyft. How do you figure out what's going on?23 answers | 18.8k views
- There is a 15% drop in the open rate of Instagram App. You are the PM. Tell us what could have happened.11 answers | 10.1k views
- There is a data point that indicates that there are more Uber drop-offs at the airport than pick-ups from the airport. Why is this the case and what would you do within the product to change that?10 answers | 22k views
- See Problem Solving PM Interview Questions
Top Amazon interview questions
- How would you improve Amazon?14 answers | 35k views
- How would you determine if a specific block in your neighborhood is suitable for a new grocery store?14 answers | 13.4k views
- You have a grocery delivery service that delivers food within 24 hours. How many trucks would you need to operate it?12 answers | 29.8k views
- See Amazon PM Interview Questions
Top Problem Solving interview questions
- You are a PM at Uber or Ola. You have to upsell Uber Go to Uber Auto customers. How would you go about it? What product changes would you make?9 answers | 3.5k views
- Utilization went down by 45% on app XYZ in Italy for the month of August. Give a reason why and draft a plan to fix it.7 answers | 3k views
- New users signing up for FB are not returning after 30 days. How will you identify the problem? Discuss solutions to that.7 answers | 13.4k views
- See Problem Solving PM Interview Questions