You'll get access to over 3,000 product manager interview questions and answers
Recommended by over 100k members
Describe Product: Hashtags are used to provide power to a movement or some common idea/thought/event. This helps user find other posts with same hastag and see what other people are posting and read comments and impact of popularity by # of post with same hashtag, impressions, comments etc.
Clarify: I am assuming hashtags are there for a while, so the product is in growth stage.
Goal: Based on above assumption, I will set the goal as Engagement and Retention.
User journey:
1. User creates post with certain hashtag(s)
2. User can access other posts with same hastag(s) and see how popular user idea is or what other people are posting,
3. users can comment on similar posts, make connection with content creator or follow the creator.
Metrics:
1. # of posts with hashtags per month
2. # of hashtags created per month
3. % of active users who create at least one hashtag post per month.
4. Avearge # of comments per 1000 posts with hashtags/ Avearge # of comments per 1000 posts without hashtags
Evaluate:
Prioritize: # of posts with hashtags per month
Other will be scondary metrics
How would you go about setting goals for Instagram hashtags?
metrics | Creators | Consumers |
Awareness / Activation | 1.1 Ave % of tagged posts per creator 1.2 Ave # of tags per post | 1.1 Ave # of tag searches per user (search box) 1.2 Ave # of clicks on a hashtag per user (hashtag in a post) 1.3 % of open emails / push notifications related to hashtags |
Engagement | 2.1 Ave # of shares+likes+comments per post with hashtags as opposed to a look-alike post without Meaningfullness of the convos: 2.2 Ave depth of a thread for a post with hashtags as opposed to a look-alike post without 2.3 % of consumers who followed a creator after clicking on a hashtag | |
Retention | 3.1 DAU for creators who use hashtags vs those who don't | 3.1 WAU for users who have clicked on at least one hashtag in the last 7 days 3.2 Average weekly time spent in the app after clicking on hashtag |
Other metrics | Measure the popularity / trendiness of a hashtag 4.1 For hashtags that achieved top 1% in terms of number of clicks - how long do they stay in top 1%. 4.2 What are the most popular categories across time- could use this to encourage creators to focus on more desired topics of interest |
5. Evaluation / prioritization
I'll evaluate and prioritize the metrics based on their alignment with the goal we've outlined as well as the complexity of measurement - e.g. while it might be interesting to learn about 4.1 (trendiness of hashtags), I'd assume it's fairly complicated to query and hence it won't be prioritized high.
As a north star metric, in order to ensure hashtags indeed help people discover interesting content and bring people together - I'd choose 1.2 - Ave # of clicks on a hashtag per user. This indicates interest in tagged topics, usage of the feature and drives downstream engagement metrics.
Other primary metrics would be - 1.1 Ave % of tagged posts per creator, since we need creators to add the tags in order to maintaint the ecosystem, and 2.1 - Ave # of shares+likes+comments per post with hashtags as opposed to a look-alike post without, since we want to ensure engagement is, indeed, increasing following the tagging.
As secondary metrics I'd look at the retention bucket, to monitor the healthiness of the ecosystem as a whole.
6. Summary
To measure the success of hashtags, which goal is to help people find content, I'd focus on average number of hashtag clicks per user and compliment it with several engagement and retention metrics.
Step1: Define the feature
On Instagram, by placing the pound symbol in front of a word or phrase, the term becomes a clickable phrase. When users click that link, they’ll be taken to a page that displays all posts that also utilize that hashtag.
It's a way to categorize and group similar content together. For example, clicking the hashtag “#travelgram” that appears in an Instagram post will take you to a page where you can see other travel-related posts:
Using relevant hashtags makes it easier for users to stumble upon your account. They might see a post of yours when perusing different hashtags, and then decide that you’re worth a follow—meaning hashtags are a great way to grow your audience.
Posts that use hashtags get far more engagement. In fact, one study goes so far as to say that Instagram posts that use at least one hashtag get 12.6% more engagement.
They’re easy to implement. Sure, they’ll require a little research and planning to make sure you identify the right hashtags to use (more on that a little later!). But, beyond that, they’re an incredibly simple way to expand your following and give your engagement a boost.
Step 2: Feature goal
Feature goals are different for different user groups
Content Creators
Get more followers
Improve post engagement
Build community around your business
Content Consumers
Easily find relevant content and engage
Step 3: user Journey
Example - A food blogger might post a picture of a gorgeous smoothie bowl, and then use the hashtags #superfoods, #cleaneating, and #vegansofig when it’s uploaded to Instagram -> By using these three hashtags, the image is cataloged so other Instagram users who enjoy healthy foods can easily find it when they search / follow these hashtags
User can then engage with the post in many ways - follow, unfollow, like, comment, save, share etc
Step 4: Map user behavior with user journey phase
Content Creators
Get more followers
No. of followers of a hashtag (shows the popularity)
No. of new followers acquired by a content creator through hashtag search
% Increase in avg. no. of followers per post
Improve post engagement
Avg. No. of reactions for post with hashtag Vs posts without hashtag
Avg. no. of saves , shares for post with hashtag Vs posts without hashtag
Avg. no. of comments
Impression of each hashtag
% Increase in time spent on IG per user
Content Consumers
Easily find relevant content and engage
% increase in Hashtag search
% conversion of users to followers for hashtag search
Step 5: Evaluate the metrics and Prioritize
Given the impact to the user and business the metrics I’d like to track are
% Increase in avg. no. of followers per post
Avg. No. of reactions for post with hashtag Vs posts without hashtag
Avg. no. of saves , shares for post with hashtag Vs posts without hashtag
Avg. no. of comments for posts with hashtags Vs posts without hashtags
Before we start setting goals for hashtags let's figure out why they exist and why instagram existing.
Instagrams mission is to capture's the world moments - this could be with friends or the world or anything that can be captured on a camera.
Hashtags could refer to something in the pic itself or to a deeper meaning like an inside joke or an abstract term.
Goal
we want to aid the consumers(users who browse) in discovering these moments/photographs through hashtags and also enable the creators to reach a larger audience.
Users can either click on a hashtag and discover content or they can follow a hashtag and keep discovering content related. In addition there are certain hashtags that are topical vs those that are ever green
I want to break the success metrics down into consumers and creator metrics as follows
Creator
- Primary: % of posts created with hashtags vs without
- % of users discovering posts(viewing) via hashtags vs other channels of discovery ( explore etc)
- % of users following account via hashtags
- % of users following hashtags themselves
- Primary: % of total posts consumed(viewed) via hastags
- Timespent in hashtag discovery experience
- % of users finding hashtags useful ( liked a post or followed an account or a hashtag via hashtags)
- Top hashtags over different time period (split by topical and ever green)
Summarising the approach
IG's mission
how do hashtags align with the mission
who are the different user cohorts consuming hashtags
What metrics align with the cohorts and what is the primary metric
Clarify
Setting goals for Instagram hashtags ~ define what success looks like for Instagram hashtags?
Assuming, this is for the current hashtag product (as it stands).
Define why hashtag exist?
- I think hashtags in Instagram exist so users can easily tag content and discover content based on these tags.
- They serve both as filters and amplifiers of content on Facebook. It's important to realize that (1). Filters help narrow the focus, while (2). Amplifiers help increase or improve a signal.
- How would you define hashtag's existence on a meta-level?
Mission & Goal
Metrics
Since the feature is useful for discovery. We identified earlier that it acts as both filter and amplifier (analogy). We want to choose metrics that define success as functions of the two attributes above:
- % of new posts on Instagram with hashtags - this tells us what percentage of new posts on Instagram are being tagged appropriately for discovery. Growth of this # may lead to success.
- % of hashtags that grow/used exponentially - this gives a trend line of hashtag usage in general. We will want to see how this % increases or remains proportionate if #1 goes up. This metric accesses the amplifying nature of hashtags and validates our theory of whether this is being achieved or not.
- The half-life of exponential hashtags (lifetime value): Average half-life of hashtags that grow viral - this tells us when to expect hashtags expiry and find another way to make content relevant. It will also tell us if certain golden tags are timeless. More variants of those tags are good.
- # of new connections/follows per week initiated via a hashtag search or hashtag discovery - the central idea of making sure that discovery leads to bringing people together. This metric track engagement and the ability to interconnect.
Prioritization
Metric | Priority (1 to 5) 5 = highest |
1 | 4 |
4 | 5 |
2 | 4 |
3 | 3 |
I would pick #1 and #4 as my success indicators.
Summary
- We defined the existence of hashtags today in light of Facebook and Instagram's mission.
- Identified goals for hashtags and how it is aligned with the overarching goals.
- Identified key attributes of hashtags and enumerated metrics for success.
- Prioritized metrics to track success towards the product's goal.
1) What do you mean by setting goals, is it something that is related to company's current objective or do you want me to assume that? (Measuring the success of instagram hashtags is the goal for this feature).
2) Are we considering hashtags on/for a particular part of the instagram ecosystem/product or for the entire instagram product.
Step 2: Talk and explain your understanding of the product
Instagram hashtags is used to discover more related content, reach to a wider audience. Instagram hashtags are generally used by 2 kinds of users
Businesses use hashtags to reach and market to a larger audience of people.
Inidvidual users like social media influencers, artists, and celebrities, end consumers use hashtags to reach a large audience of people with their content.
Hashtags can be used in/with various different forms of content like articles, posts, video, IGTV. It is a way of discovering and engaging with new users/people.
Hashtags has been there for a very long period of time and has seen amazing user adoption by people who are part of the instagram ecosystem.
Once you put a hashtag a clickable link comes/appears and you can press on the link/hashtag to see more more different kinds of content that use the same hashtag thus is used for user discovery.
Step 3: Identify and define the goal of the product
The goal of instagram hashtags is to reach more people (audience), engage with more people and make content more easily discoverable.
Thus for instagram hashtags we can have various goals such as driving user engagement, increasing user retention etc all of this which in turn leads to business growth and increase in revenue for instagram.
Step 4: List down the user actions
1) User logs in to their instagram account
2) User scrolls through the news feed, doesn't find anything interesting
3) Wants to put out some content on their own in the form of posts
4) User creates a post and since the users have spent nothing on marketing because of lack of time, uses hashtags to reach to new audience and make/discover more similar content
Step 5: List down the metrics that is aligned to the final goal of the product
1) User Engagement
Average Number of likes, comments, and shares per post which has hashtags
Average number of hashtags per user in a month's time
Total number of hashtags in a daily/weekly and monthly basis
% of new users (not in a person's network) who comment like and share on posts which have hashtags
2) User Retention
Number of # used per user on a daily/weekly and monthly basis
Ave number of users who use # even after 3 months
% of users who have used at least 5# in the past 1 month
Step 6: Evaluate and prioritise the metrics
As a PM for Instagram #, i will prioritise the metrics listed in step 5 based on the following factors
Relevance to end goal and mission of the company and product, Impact to end user and effort required to collect the metrics.
So we will be consdidering one primary metric (should be broad in nature) and 1-2 secondary metrics.
Total number of hashtags used on a daily/weekly and monthly basis will be used as the primary metric to measure the success of instagram hashtags
For the secondary metric to measure the success of instagram hashtags we will be using average number of likes/comment and shares per post (post type)
Thus these are the metrics that we will use to measure the success for instagram hashtags
Product description:
Just so that we are on the same page about Instagram hashtags, this feature is used by users on posts to increase discoverability of their posts and share them with a broader community. It aligns with the mission of Instagram which is to capture moments of life and share them with the world.
Clarifying questions:
Do we know anything else about this feature? No
Business goal:
My hypothesis is that the primary business goal of this feature is to increase engagement as broader outreach would mean more activity on a post in the form of likes, comments,or shares and lead to an increased engagement of original post creator as well as post consumers
Users and user journey:
- Content creators: Create posts, use hashtags, check if their post is getting traction, check if they are getting more followers
- Content consumers: Browse their feed, interact with the posts, tap on a hashtag to disover posts related to a theme, start following someone etc.
Goals and metrics:
Adoption:
- % of DAU who who have used hashtags
Usage and Engagement
- #DAUs of hashtag users
- #Hashtags per post
- #Hashtags per day
- #Posts per Hashtag
- Distribution of hashtags per category
- Increase in activity on posts (views, likes, comments, shares, followers) with and without hashtags
- A/B tests: Did it lead to an increased creation of posts, increased time spent per user, increased number of sessions per week
- # of times a recommendation works vs. a custom one created by a user
Retention:
- Weekly reuse of this feature
Counter Metrics:
- Gamification by users to get more activity on their posts
- Incorrect categorization
- Time taken to create post i.e. how many times do users create post and stop while being in the middle of adding hashtags
Top Meta (Facebook) interview questions
- What is your favorite product? Why?89 answers | 263k views
- How would you design a bicycle renting app for tourists?62 answers | 82.5k views
- Build a product to buy and sell antiques.54 answers | 66.8k views
- See Meta (Facebook) PM Interview Questions
Top Metrics interview questions
- How would you measure the success of Facebook Likes?40 answers | 61.3k views
- What metrics would you use to measure the success of the Save feature at Facebook? 39 answers | 87.2k views
- How would you measure the success of Gmail?23 answers | 17k views
- See Metrics PM Interview Questions
Top Metrics interview questions
- What metrics would you look at as a product manager for Instagram ads?19 answers | 23.8k views
- What is the most important metric for Google Docs and why?19 answers | 15.3k views
- What goals would you set for a Facebook Dating feature?14 answers | 9.4k views
- See Metrics PM Interview Questions